Discussion about this post

User's avatar
UncleMac's avatar

If our economy is doing so well, why am I finding it difficult to pay my bills where I didn't used to struggle at all? The sovereign debt fund will be a Liberal slush fund; that's how they roll.

Symmetrade's avatar

If we can assume that economic growth is largely driven by the volume of money creation and credit allocation, then the Canadian economy is presumably growing because more money is being created and spent, which is perhaps reflected in the size of the federal deficit, so it might be better for the federal government to keep running a deficit if it plans on spending money on new public projects.

Likewise, if the private sector’s savings comes from government deficits, then deficit spending and tax cuts do help more people to save more money, which we can then supposedly invest directly in the Canada Strong Fund.

If government spending precedes tax collection then the federal government doesn’t need to worry about collecting or raising taxes to pay for these projects.

As you have noted, public debt charges are projected at $58.7 billion for 2026-27.

If the government plans to borrow from the Bank of Canada then, as you pointed out, the Bank will buy new federal bonds and create corresponding deposits for the government (simply creating new money by making digital accounting entries). The Bank typically remits profits to the federal treasury—but it looks like the Bank didn’t remit any money to the government last year. And it does seem a little odd for the government to pay interest to its own bank so that the bank can then remit some of that money to the government.

But it seems crazy for the government to pay interest to the commercial banks for money that they will also create with the click of a keyboard.

Perhaps the problem isn’t so much who creates the money, but how it is created and for what purpose.

Perhaps it would be preferable and more cost-effective for the Bank of Canada to provide zero-interest financing to the federal government for the entire amount for any productive public projects...but that seems unlikely.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?