Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ken Fisher's avatar

" ... one in four Canadians claims to have personally witnessed an unidentified anomalous phenomenon in their lifetime. Despite this widespread exposure across the population, a staggering 90 percent of these witnesses never formally report what they saw."

Entropy's avatar

Well, and as always thoughtfully, written. Nevertheless, IMO you’ve not made a convincing case that “dangerous” is a term that can reasonably be applied to this gap in data collection, analysis and reporting.

“Recognizing that Canada has dangerously fallen behind its international allies[…]”

Particularly not with all the new, more immediate and far more convincingly dangerous priorities which now compete for the focus of our efforts and limited resources.

If a case could be made that a significant percentage of sightings which have been investigated result in the identification of a foreign national intrusion risking our national security, that may justify the effort described by the report’s recommendations.

Instead, the major harm in continuing to focus efforts elsewhere seems to be reputational — “See, Janice, I *told* you the government’s hiding aliens from us and is using their gizmos to spy on (slash control) us!”

A rational, evidence-based, approach to collecting, analyzing and reporting these sightings is not going to make much headway against these folks. We’d probably achieve almost as much by simply maintaining a couple of web pages hosting the case against UAP sightings as indicators of extraterrestrial visitors, with sections written by various Canadian subject experts explaining the typical breakdown in annual sightings — including, delicately, what percentage are multi-reports by the same small number of individuals or groups.

There are many more reasons to continue as we are, for the moment at least, than to create a new UAP reporting system. Let’s give ourselves 10 years to make the dramatic, *necessary*, expensive and disruptive changes nationally to accommodate the new world that has been thrust upon us, and then see if we have the bandwidth to spare for this low priority effort.

No posts

Ready for more?